In the vast, unpredictable frontier of Red Dead Redemption 2, there are encounters that blur the line between myth, madness, and morality. One such encounter takes place when you’re tracking down the legendary gunslinger Jim “Boy” Callaway. This guide walks you through the narrative beats and offers insights into how to handle the tense situations that follow, including a dark secret hidden beneath a local gunsmith’s shop.

Meeting Jim “Boy” Callaway

Your journey begins with what seems like a dead end. Jim “Boy” Callaway, once fabled to be the fastest left-handed draw west of the Mississippi, is now just a drunken shell of a man. When you approach him, the conversation quickly becomes erratic. He brushes off his own legend, insisting it was just a lot of bunk—nonsense. But the man beside him insists otherwise, emphasizing Callaway’s past deeds and mysterious reputation.

Despite the confusion and insults flying, including Callaway angrily yelling at you to leave, the scene sets the tone for what kind of person he has become: a volatile and bitter old man, clinging to faded glory. Still, this is only the surface—Callaway is more than a sad drunk. What he represents is tied deeply to the myths of the Old West, and uncovering his truth is an essential thread in your journey through the Gunslingers mission line.

The Gunsmith’s Basement – A Hidden Nightmare

Later in your travels, you arrive in a quiet town with an unassuming gunsmith. Initially, everything seems routine until a string of oddities begins to unfold. The gunsmith greets you with weariness, complaining of stomach pains and being in no mood for guests. His disinterest seems like nothing at first—just the tired groaning of a shopkeep. But then, strange noises and muffled cries begin to rise from below the floorboards.

When confronted and pressured about the basement, the gunsmith attempts to brush it off. However, persistence is key. With enough pressure, he gives in and reveals a shocking truth: he’s holding a young man captive downstairs, chained and dressed bizarrely due to the gunsmith’s twisted fantasies. The boy, clearly traumatized, begs for your help.

You’re given a choice here, though it’s not presented as a direct one. You can loot the place, free the boy, or walk away and pretend you never saw anything. But the right thing is clear—liberate the victim. The game offers no morality meter pop-up in this case, but your own code is what counts. This moment is emblematic of Red Dead Redemption 2’s strength in presenting moral ambiguity. There’s no glory here, only a grim sense of justice.

Backroom Dealings and Shady Business

If your journey leads you to investigate another backroom—perhaps in a different shop or saloon—you might encounter yet another scene of tension. The front may be clean, but knock hard enough and you’ll uncover illicit dealings. When you demand to see what’s behind a closed door, you’re warned off. But with the right force, the door opens.

Behind it: an illegal gambling den or some other unsavory business. The men inside are armed, curt, and engaged in something they don’t want eyes on. This isn’t a simple robbery—it’s a confrontation. As you step into the room, chaos can erupt quickly. Firefights are likely, and backup may be nearby. Use cover, aim true, and prepare to flee if the heat gets too high. These moments reward players who have built up their Dead Eye and weapon skills.

Pushing Through Canyon Crossfire

Finally, you may find yourself trailing enemies up a canyon path. Here, you’re joined by allies who help cover your advance. Coordination and movement are crucial. Don’t rush—methodically pick off enemies while pushing up. Use the high ground when possible and watch for enemies flanking from behind or taking cover above you.

Take note that in sequences like this, ammo and health items are crucial. Restock before you set out, and don’t be afraid to use Dead Eye liberally—it may be the difference between making it through or being forced to reload.

---

Final Thoughts

Red Dead Redemption 2’s world is dense with stories that often aren’t spelled out with clear heroes or villains. The Callaway subplot and the disturbing gunsmith basement scene are prime examples of Rockstar’s commitment to immersive, unsettling storytelling. You’re not just an outlaw here—you’re a witness to the collapse of the mythic West, and your decisions carry weight beyond just bullets fired. Stay sharp, stay skeptical, and keep your hand near your holster. There’s always more than meets the eye out on the frontier.